Thursday, April 23, 2015

Sophie's Choice

Sophie's Choice by William Styron

Blog written by Sharon

This novel was written in 1979 and won the National Book Award for Fiction in 1980.  Most of us have seen the movie starring Meryl Streep but many have forgotten the storyline so it was interesting to read the novel this time round.

We agree that the choice of the title is a clever one as it doesn't apply only to one choice that Sophie had to make, but rather several choices throughout the novel : between her children obviously, between Nathan and Stingo, between lying and telling the truth, between choosing to live or die...

I personally thought that Styron was clever to introduce slavery into a Holocaust story.  He says  : " It is important to regard Auschwitz as the recrudescence of slavery, the first in western civilisation since the American Civil war".

Which brings us to the many elaborate and complicated vocabulary throughout the book -- made me appreciate reading it on the Kindle with a built-in dictionary !!

Music is an important strain in the novel as are literary figures and works mentioned. In particular the poems of Emily Dickens and works of Tom Wolfe.

I thought that Styron was skilled at creating multi dimensional characters but may have portrayed the women in his novel skewed from a male's viewpoint.

The average rating of the book was 8/10 with quite a few 9s.  It was described as "harrowing".
We agreed that it generated a lot of interesting discussions and points of view.

Our next book is We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves by Karen Joy Fowler and the meeting will take place at Sarah's on Wednesday May 20th ( instead of Thursday May 21st ).

Big Little Lies

Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty

Comments from Sarah :

I enjoyed the book, found the domestic violence harrowing and thought the characters were well written. Thanks for the choice, I didn't know anything about Liane Moriaty before I bought it. Thought it a salutary take on suburban life and the deceptiveness  of appearances!

Other members described it as :
"Interesting story and format"
"Seemed like the Slap initially"
"Touched on domestic abuse and kind of ropes you in"
"Compelling reading"
"Characters were well written"

We rated the book 7/10

Our next book is Sophie's Choice by William Styron and we will be meeting on April 23 Thursday at Sharon's.

The Gold Finch Feb 2015

The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt

Our first meeting of the year and we met at Jane's  in Feb 2015.

The book has been described as "brilliant" although some felt it was a bit of a let down at the end.

Lee's comments :
"Huge book, I loved every page until towards the end with the strange business in Amsterdam and the conclusion and the author's summing up as it were at the end.  I didn't feel that it was a particularly 'literary' work but nevertheless a great read."

Ratings averaged 7-8/10

Our next book is Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty and will be on Thursday March 12 at Megan's.